Buyers ask: "How Much Should We Offer For This House?"

Perhaps the most common question would-be home buyers ask me is "What do you think this house will sell for?".  (Actually, homeOWNERS ask the same question).

The real, honest answer is: "Whatever someone is willing to pay for it."  Since we don't have a Crystal Ball, no one can predict the final selling price.  It all depends on how many offers there are on a house, and how badly someone wants it.  Incidentally, I don't like the term "bidding war", because that is really not correct or descriptive of the process.  But here are a couple of guidelines to help us along in the process:

If the house has been on the market for a few weeks, or even months (yes, that DOES happen, even in Winnipeg), and the owner and their agent have never adjusted the price, the buyer might try something a little lower than asking-price.  Provided that the buyer (with his own agent)  has done some comparing and homework, and assuming that the listing price of the house is not 'pie-in-the-sky-dreamin', an offer of a few thousand below asking price might be accepted.

If the house is 'taking offers' on a given date, and the buyer is lucky enough not to have to compete, putting in an offer of full-asking price might not be a bad idea.  Again, I stress that the buyer thru his agent, has performed a comparison-study of the house, and assured that it is fairly priced.  Assuming the asking price is realistic, a buyer might be well advised to count their blessings for not having to compete against a number of other buyers.

If the house in question is receiving 5, 6, (thirty?) offers, then all bets are off.  I've seen some pretty scary and ridiculous things happen in a case like this, and my best advice to my buyer would be: "Write your best offer....your walk-away price".  In other words, if the house goes for more than your offer, you feel you've given it your best shot and don't wake up the next day going "Doh" ala Homer Simpson.

The reason that 'bidding war' is somewhat of a misnomer: In a case of so many offers, the process is really pretty simple.....put your best offer forward and hope for the best.  On the plus side, at least you will find out almost immediately (within hours, anyway) whether your offer is accepted.

I've had a few buyers who have tried to buy a "Private Sale", and were left hanging for a week before being rejected.  In their case, they could not go out and pursue other homes, while their offers, (along with the deposit cheques) languished in the home-owners hands.  It seems that some private sellers are being 'coached' to hold on to offers and tell the buyers that they have to "think about it?".  Then, during the next week, while they are no doubt thinking hard, they are also 'shopping the offer around'. 

Please remember this:  yes, the market is hot, competition for homes is fierce.  However, homes listed with Realtors still have certain rules to follow, whereas private sellers are pretty much left unregulated.  Its 'buyer beware' to the extreme...

Comments

[Toronto real estate agent]

It is not only the lack of regulation in private selling/buying but also the lack of information. I mean, a private seller may or may not reveal all the specific information about the house (like major damage, etc.). I'm a Toronto real estate agent and I don't mean to insult nobody or do a little bit of extra promo, but if any private person wants to sell or buy real estate they should always ask the pro. I mean, you go to the doctors when you have a problem, don't you?

[house]

Can you post better stats than the Winnipeg RE Board can? In a quicker time?
Can you post weekly sales & listings stats like the Edmonton RE blog does?

[mortgage services]

Hi

The first thing you need to do when you find you are going to be moving to another country is find out about international movers. This is the most important factor in a smooth, successful international move.A real estate company aaamoving-store is first to provide such a quality services .just click below link to know more about their services
http://aaamoving-store.com/

[ray]

Can you post better stats than the Winnipeg RE Board can? In a quicker time?
Can you post weekly sales & listings stats like the Edmonton RE blog does

[Bo Kauffmann]

Regarding the posting of "Stats" as the Edmonton Blog does: I think the Edmonton Blog is absolutely fantastic, I really do. I would endeavor to model my blog after that one, I am really impressed with it. I do have a problem: I am rather busy selling homes, and dont find the time to collect, research, identify and post statistics, let along do it "better than the Real Estate Board".
That also leaves me with a question: Does anyone really benefit from the knowledge that 'last week there were 197 new listings, as opposed to the week before, which saw 184 new listings"....I mean, who cares......
For anyone who is looking at these stats in hopes of picking up a house 'on the cheap', or 'get a bargain', I say GOOD LUCK.
I think back on a study that was done relating to the financial investment sector: One investor invested $100 per month for 10 years, while another one took the same amount of money and tried to 'read the market' and only make investments when he thought the market was down. At the end of 10 years, their investments were nearly identitical.

If you are looking to buy a house, I hope you find some of the information in this blog helpful, and that when the time comes to buy, you contact a qualified Realtor (hey, ME perhaps??) and buy that house. If on the other hand, you just want to watch the stats, I'm afraid the R.E. Board will do a much better job than I can offer.